Vote thread for Madden League Re:Playoff Tiebreaker

[Quo]

The playoff scenario is so complex that it's coming down to winning percentage against common opponents for the 4 teams that are tied for the last playoff spot.

Please only vote if you're in the league. Do you think that forfeits should count as games against common opponents?

[Woundup]

I dont believe the person who received a win should be punished by not making the playoffs. If it is not their fault the forfeited game was not played.

[Kamacauzie]

Originally Posted by Woundup

I dont believe the person who received a win should be punished by not making the playoffs. If it is not their fault the forfeited game was not played.

Cosigned. well said

[Crankbait]

I agree, lets just do 5 weeks of play-in games prior to the actual playoffs.

[Quo]

Currently 5-1 disallowing Cuse and Crippler's votes (WTH? ). As Lax is out of the league, Bomali, Shibumi and Mahkila are never around and Grenic, BrianBlair, Schlick are less frequent... plus Crank was here but didn't vote but appears to follow group sentiment...

It looks like we pretty much have an answer. I think it's correct, too, because forfeits are counting against total records and division standings. It would be inconsistent to disallow them for tiebreakers. Kinda stinks, I hate tiebreakers but it is what it is. Speak up now or forever hold your peace!

I'm headed over to the main thread to make the update and the current playoff situation.

[Crippler]

The poll is on the front page....so you're gonna get votes from everyone possibly hitting the front page. That's how my vote got in there.

[Quo]

whoops. Dude, I value your opinion. It's all good.