If youve got the 40 bones laying around, go for it. If I needed a diversion, Id dive back into Oblivion(lord knows I have 500 hours left)
Oh and I puked a little when you mentioned 1up. I'd trust my dog more

I dont base any game purchase on any websites reviews, but they are jthe worst of the worst. If its got a Rockstar or Square label on it, they will praise it, unless its on a MS or Nintendo console ofcourse
Offtopic but seeing as you mentioned some ps2 titles, go post your Favs here...
List your Top 25 games of All-Time