| You have to go fishing and catch a fish. I caught like 10 fish before it worked for me. I was original fishing by the pier where the cat is staring at the water. I then moved to a different spot and instead if it dropping the fish back into the water (it makes you drop them as it says they are common) it dropped the fish on the land, you'll see what happens next.
Gamecube version (I'm sure it is different on the Wii) Something I didn't get at first for fishing is that it takes no skill at all (which means I couldn't figure it out at first, lol). When you snag something you have to hold the stick, that is it. I thought you might have to time it or tap it, etc. but nope just pull bag and that is it. | 
